Remove or Remodel Your Pool? How to Decide

Worn Phoenix pool viewed from a covered patio

If your pool is sound and you still want a backyard you can enjoy, remodeling is usually the stronger move: it typically costs less than building new and keeps a feature many buyers in the Phoenix area expect. Removal makes sense in narrower cases, mostly when the shell is failing past the point of reasonable repair or you truly need the yard space. This guide gives you the checks that settle the question, the real costs on both sides, and what filling in a pool involves if you go that way.

Wefixuglypools
wefixuglypools.com
Give Your Pool a New Lease on Life
Wefixuglypools specializes in pool remodeling, custom features, and repairs for homeowners with tired or unappealing pools in Greater Phoenix.

Explore pool remodeling

TL;DR

  • Start with the shell. A structurally sound shell with worn surfaces, tile, equipment or looks is a remodel candidate. A shell that needs major structural work may tip toward removal.
  • In Phoenix, a typical remodel runs $12,000โ€“$20,000, or $15,000โ€“$30,000 with upgrades. Removal costs vary by pool size, access and fill method; call (602) 253-4499 for a quote. Removal ends the cost of upkeep but also ends the pool.
  • Fill-in is not a weekend job. It needs a permit in most places, inspections, and properly compacted fill. A partial fill-in must be disclosed when you sell.
  • Never drain a pool on your own to find out what is wrong. An emptied shell can crack or lift out of the ground.
  • In a hot-weather market, a refreshed pool often supports your homeโ€™s appeal. Check with a local agent before you decide.

Table of Contents

The Short Answer: Which Fits Your Pool?

Most homeowners who search this question are living with a pool that looks tired, leaks, or costs too much to run. That is a different problem from not wanting a pool at all. Sort yourself into one of these groups:

Your situation Usually points to
Faded plaster, stained or missing tile, dated deck, old equipment Remodel
Sound shell, but the shape or depth no longer suits your family Remodel (depth conversion, new features)
Leaks traced to plumbing or equipment Repair or remodel
Widespread structural cracking, repeated failed repairs Get an engineerโ€™s or builderโ€™s assessment before spending
Pool takes up most of the yard and nobody will ever swim in it Removal is worth pricing
You plan to build an addition on the footprint Complete removal, not a partial fill-in

The rest of this article explains why.

Start With the Shell, Not the Cosmetics

Cosmetic damage looks dramatic and costs little compared with what is underneath. Peeling plaster, stained tile and a cracked coping stone are surface issues. The shell and the plumbing are what determine whether a remodel pays off.

Professional guidance published in AQUA Magazine in January 2026 says there is no universal percentage rule for saving a shell, though some experts consider removing more than 30% of an otherwise sound shell a point where complete removal may be more economical. It recommends core testing, and a shell compressive strength of at least 4,000 PSI. That is the kind of data a qualified pool builder can gather, so you are not guessing from the surface.

Concrete core sample from a pool shell

The same guidance covers what you cannot see. Underground plumbing can hide leaks and corrosion, and it recommends replacing questionable plumbing rather than trying to preserve it. It also treats pumps older than six years as suspect. In practice, that means a remodel budget should include new plumbing and equipment as line items from the start, so nothing old is quietly carried forward.

What a thorough assessment covers

  1. Visual check of the shell for cracks, hollow spots and settlement.
  2. Leak detection to separate shell leaks from plumbing and equipment leaks.
  3. Review of the plumbing runs, pump, filter and heater age.
  4. Condition of the surface, tile, coping and deck.
  5. Whether the shape and depth still fit how you use the pool.

If you are weighing repair against a full renovation, our guide on pool renovation vs repair walks through that decision in more detail.

What Remodeling a Pool Costs

Remodel costs vary widely because โ€œremodelโ€ covers everything from a new finish to a full redesign. In the Phoenix area, a typical remodel with We Fix Ugly Pools runs $12,000โ€“$20,000, or $15,000โ€“$30,000 with upgrades. A resurfacing and waterline tile refresh typically runs $8,000โ€“$15,000. On its own, plaster resurfacing runs $6,500โ€“$9,000, quartz $8,500โ€“$12,000, and pebble $10,000โ€“$15,000. Waterline tile runs $1,500โ€“$5,000, and coping runs $40โ€“$80 per foot. In Arizona sun and hard water, plaster lasts 5โ€“7 years, quartz 12โ€“18, and pebble 25โ€“30. New builds run $38,000โ€“$60,000, so a remodel usually costs less than starting over.

Pool remodel cost ranges and project examples

The point is that your own number depends on scope. A resurfacing and tile refresh is a very different project from converting a deep end or relocating equipment. We price each project after looking at the pool, because the shell condition drives everything else.

Where remodel money tends to do the most good

If the shell passes inspection, the upgrades with the most visible payoff are usually the finish, the tile, the deck and a focal feature. We cover this in four pool upgrades that deliver the most visual impact, and if your budget is modest, three moves for a modern pool look shows how far a focused scope can go.

What Removing a Pool Actually Involves

The phrase โ€œfill in my poolโ€ covers two very different jobs.

  • Partial fill-in. The top portion of the shell is broken down below grade, the floor is perforated so water cannot collect, and the rest of the shell stays buried. The upper range in the Realtor.com guide is to break the shell down by 18 to 36 inches.
  • Full removal. The entire shell, plumbing and equipment pad come out and the excavation is backfilled.

They are different scopes with different long-term consequences. Santa Rosaโ€™s official demolition policy warns that partial demolition and uncompacted backfill may cause differential settlement, limits the area to open, landscape or garden use, and requires the owner to disclose the buried shell at sale. The City of San Mateoโ€™s abandonment guide says complete demolition should be used when a future structure may occupy the pool site.

Those are California cities, so your own cityโ€™s rules will differ in the details. The pattern holds, though: permits, inspections, compaction and disclosure.

Safe fill-in practice

Per the Realtor.com guide, in most places demolition and fill-in require a permit. Utilities should be cut back to the source, capped and documented. Clean fill should be placed in compacted lifts of 8 to 12 inches, not dumped in all at once, and drainage should be corrected afterward. Poorly compacted fill is why a former pool can settle and dip years later.

Drainage after backfill matters as much as the fill itself. If you are thinking about the landscape side, this overview of fixing yard drainage with grade rules is a good place to start.

Do not drain the pool first

Whether you remodel or remove, emptying the pool is the riskiest step. The SPPA, a professional association, calls draining one of the highest-risk operations in the pool industry. A full poolโ€™s water balances groundwater pressure, and once drained, pressure beneath the shell can crack it, shift it or lift it out of the ground. Improper draining is also tied to some of the most severe insurance claims, along with flooding and runoff onto neighboring properties.

The lesson for homeowners: let a professional decide whether and how to drain, and plan where thousands of gallons will go.

Cost Comparison: Remodel vs. Fill-In vs. Full Removal

Published national cost guides overlap and often disagree, so we use our Phoenix figures below, not national averages. Treat these as typical ranges, not a quote.

Option Phoenix-area range Notes
Pool remodel $12,000โ€“$20,000 typical, or $15,000โ€“$30,000 with upgrades We Fix Ugly Pools, Phoenix
Fill-in (partial or complete) and full removal Costs vary by pool size, access and fill method Call (602) 253-4499 for a quote. We do not publish a flat removal price.

Removal costs vary by pool size, access and fill method, so call (602) 253-4499 for a quote. Remodel ranges are in the table above. Costs rise with size, material and access to the yard.

At first glance, removal looks cheaper. But that comparison leaves out what you end up with. Removal spends money to get rid of an asset. A remodel spends money to make it work for you and your family again.

What Happens to Your Homeโ€™s Value

This is where homeowners get the most conflicting advice. Kiplinger, citing National Association of Realtors data, reports that only 1% of agents recommend adding a pool before selling. That speaks to building from scratch right before a sale. It says little about a pool you already own that can be restored to good condition.

PoolMagazine.com says a well-executed remodel can raise the value of the home itself. A pool is also one of the first things buyers inspect. Our checklist of what buyers look for in pools shows the specifics, and our piece on pool renovation market timing helps you plan around a sale.

If a sale is on the horizon, talk to a local agent or appraiser about how pools are valued in your neighborhood. A reference such as common home appraisal pitfalls explains how appraisers think about property features in general.

A partial fill-in adds a paperwork wrinkle: HomeLight notes it must be disclosed to buyers, and Santa Rosaโ€™s policy requires disclosure at sale. That is something to price into any removal decision.

Fill-In Rules and Rebates in Arizona

In the Phoenix area, rules come from your city, so confirm with your municipalityโ€™s building department before any work. One local example of how seriously cities treat the process: Scottsdale Waterโ€™s pool removal rebate requires a pre-inspection, a Notice to Proceed, a demolition permit and post-completion documentation. The 2026 application lists $400 plus $2 per square foot of water surface, capped at $1,500, for eligible in-ground pools of at least 150 square feet. It also requires that the pool be filled even if a deck or building goes above it, and it bars replacing the pool with water-intensive features or high-water-use plants.

Rebate terms change, so use the cityโ€™s official page for the current program. For remodel work, permits matter too. Our guide to Phoenix pool remodel permits explains which changes can trigger required upgrades, and equipment relocation covers how to avoid permit delays.

A Decision Framework You Can Use Tonight

Answer these in order:

  1. Is the shell sound? If a builderโ€™s assessment says yes, remodeling stays on the table, and most of your costs are surface, tile and equipment.
  2. Is the plumbing and equipment old? Budget to replace it either way you remodel.
  3. Do you or your family actually want to use a pool? If yes, removal solves a problem you do not have.
  4. Is the yard the real issue? If the pool dominates the space, a reshaped or smaller-footprint design may solve it without losing the pool, and a depth conversion can make a deep pool more usable.
  5. Are you selling soon? Get a local agentโ€™s view, and compare what a refreshed pool does for buyer appeal.
  6. Will you build on the footprint? Then only complete removal fits.

If you answer yes to the first and third, remodel. That describes most of the pools we see.

Our Perspective

Most pools we are called to look at are not beyond saving. They are tired. The plaster is rough, the tile is stained, the equipment is old, and the pool no longer matches the home it sits behind. Homeowners feel embarrassed by it and start to wonder whether it would be easier to fill it in.

Our focus is turning ugly pools into pools people are proud of. Over a decade and hundreds of transformations, we have also fixed work that earlier contractors got wrong, which has taught us to look hard at the shell, the plumbing and the equipment before recommending a scope.

Our advice: get the structure assessed first, then decide. If the bones are good, a remodel gives you a safer, better-looking pool that your family can use right away. If you want something different, we also build custom gunite pools with the features you choose, from water features to lighting.

Brian

Get an Honest Look at Your Pool

If you are standing at the edge of a pool you are not sure about, we can inspect the shell, plumbing and equipment, and show you what a remodel would involve for your specific pool. We handle pool resurfacing, tile, plaster, plumbing and leak repairs, depth conversions and custom features across the Greater Phoenix area. We Fix Ugly Pools has served Phoenix since 2001 and has completed 20,000+ pools. Phoenix-area homeowners can call (602) 253-4499 or use our contact form. See everything on our pool repair page and pool remodeling page. We will give you a clear scope based on what we find, so you can decide with real information.

Wefixuglypools

We will give you a clear scope based on what we find, so you can decide with real information.

FAQ

Is removing an inground pool expensive?

Removal costs vary by pool size, access and fill method. We do not publish a flat removal price, so call (602) 253-4499 for a quote. Size, material and yard access push the number up, so get a written scope that says whether the quote is for a partial or complete job.

Does a swimming pool increase or decrease the value of a home?

It depends on your market, the poolโ€™s condition and the buyer. A well-executed remodel can raise the value of the home, according to PoolMagazine.com, while advice about adding a new pool just before selling is more cautious. Ask a local agent or appraiser how pools sell in your neighborhood.

Will draining a pool damage it?

It can. Once the water is gone, groundwater pressure beneath the shell can crack it, shift it or push it out of the ground, according to the SPPA. Have a professional decide when and how to drain, and where the water will go.

Should I fill in my pool?

Consider it when the shell has failed past reasonable repair, or when the pool no longer serves your yard or your household. If the shell is sound and you still want a pool, remodeling is generally the better fit. Either way, use a permit and inspections, and ask about disclosure at sale.

Sources

Share This Post

More To Explore

Ready to Build Your Pool?

Contact us to get started!

Worlds Fastest Swimming Pool Light Features
Schedule Now